Post Your Answer
3 years ago in Academic Publishing , Research Methodology By Rutuja Pathare
Is the complete search strategy for at least one major database provided in full (e.g., in an appendix)?
 In my own work replicating reviews, I often hit a wall where the search strategy is summarized but not provided in full. This makes it impossible to verify the methodology's rigor. As a doctoral researcher, I need to know if journal standards now mandate this level of transparency, as it's fundamental to the scientific process.
All Answers (1 Answers In All)
By Rohini Singh Answered 1 year ago
In my role on editorial boards, I have seen this be a major point of contention during peer review. I would recommend that any rigorous systematic review or meta-analysis must provide the full search strategy for at least one major database, ideally in an appendix. This isn't just about transparency; it’s a cornerstone of replicability. When I advise my doctoral students, I insist on this practice. Without it, the review’s foundation cannot be audited, which significantly weakens its credibility and utility for the field.
Â
ÂReply to Rohini Singh
Related Questions