PHD Discussions Logo

Ask, Learn and Accelerate in your PhD Research

Question Icon Post Your Answer

Question Icon

Is a scientific approach to curriculum superior to a non‑scientific or humanistic approach?

I am examining philosophical assumptions underlying curriculum approaches.Scientific models emphasize evidence, structure, and measurability, while humanistic models emphasize meaning and values.This question seeks an informed comparison rather than a binary judgment.

All Answers (1 Answers In All)

By Shubham Answered 6 months ago

 From my experience in curriculum studies, I would resist framing this as an either?or choice. Scientific approaches bring rigor, clarity, and accountability, especially in STEM and skills?based learning. Humanistic approaches, however, address values, identity, ethics, and meaning—dimensions essential for holistic education. I have seen the most effective curricula integrate both: using scientific evidence to inform design while grounding learning in human experience. Balance, not dominance, produces deeper and more sustainable educational outcomes.

Your Answer