PHD Discussions Logo

Ask, Learn and Accelerate in your PhD Research

Question Icon Post Your Answer

Question Icon

1 year ago in Scholarly Etiquette By Shraddha

I suspect a graduate student in my lab is facing subtle harassment or exclusion from a co-advisor. As a senior PhD student, what is my role‑ Should I intervene, tell our main PI, or stay out of it?

I've noticed a junior student being consistently sidelined in meetings, their ideas dismissed by one particular professor, and they seem withdrawn. I'm not sure if it's my place to say anything, but it feels wrong to ignore it. What is the ethically and professionally appropriate course of action?

All Answers (1 Answers In All)

By Trideep Das Answered 3 weeks ago

Your role is that of a supportive peer and responsible community member, not a formal investigator. First, approach the junior student privately and compassionately: "I've noticed you seem quiet in meetings lately. Is everything okay? I'm here if you need to talk." Listen without pressuring. They may confirm your suspicion or have another explanation. If they disclose issues, your next step is not to confront the co-advisor but to encourage and empower them. Suggest resources: "Have you considered speaking with our main PI, the department ombudsperson, or graduate support services? I can go with you if you'd like." You can also, if you have a strong relationship with the main PI, express a general, anonymized concern about lab climate. Your duty is to offer support and guide them toward formal channels, not to mediate or accuse directly.

Your Answer